Friday, January 10, 2020

Joel & Rogers Savage: brothers with very different Revolutionary War Experiences

JOEL & ROGERS SAVAGE: BROTHERS 
WITH DIFFERING REVOLUTIONARY WAR EXPERIENCES



 
Brothers Joel and Rogers Savage both served as privates in the Army while in their teens during the Revolutionary War. They had very different experiences from each other.

My 3rd great grandfather, Rogers Savage, was twelve when the cry for independence was sounded.  Born May 14, 1764 to father William Savage, age 38, and mother Martha Gibson Savage, age 28, in Middletown, Hartford, Connecticut, Rogers was baptized as an infant in the Presbyterian Church at Middletown.  He was child number 4 of the 11 who would be born to William and Martha. His brother Joel, born Sept. 25, 1761, also in Middletown, was three years older.  Over the course of several years, the family would move from Central Connecticut to Western Massachusetts to what would become the State of New York.

A year after the Revolution commenced and while they were living in Sandisfield, Massachusetts, older brother 15-year-old Joel enlisted in the Continental Army in May 1777, for the term of three years. Immediately marching south over 100 miles to Peekskill, New York, the Massachusetts troops joined those of New York and marched another 113 miles north to Albany.  Stillwater lay 23 miles to the north of Albany where the men engaged in a severe battle against British General Burgoyne.  

This battle, now known as the Battle of Saratoga, pit 3000 fighting soldiers on either side, neither able to soundly defeat the other. To fight without being beaten was to the Americans practically a victory and, accordingly, the news of the battle was received with joy and exultation throughout America.  British General Fraser was killed and a few days after this battle, Joel was detached as a hospital guard to go to "Landingburgh".

The British retreated from Fort Stanwix after the Battle of Saratoga and the patriots never again faced a major force in upstate New York. The Iroquois and Tory raiders launched bloody hit-and-run raids on the less defended settlements and farmsteads in New York and the war continued. 

Joel returned home in the fall after his 16th birthday.  At age 18, as the British were not yet defeated, Joel again enlisted in his same Massachusetts regiment for another 6 months. After his return the following spring, his father’s family moved across the state border into Canaan, New York. 

Five months later, for reasons unknown to us, Joel enlisted as a substitute for his brother Rogers, a month before his 20th birthday. Stationed at Fort Herkimer, New York, Joel joined Captain Solomon Woodworth's company of Rangers.

A party of Indians was discovered Sept. 7, 1781. Taking rations for 7 days, Joel, one of 42 privates, the officers, 5 Stockbridge Indians and an Oneida guide, left Fort Herkimer in pursuit. Crossing West Canada Creek, the rangers chased the Indians and were ambushed.  In the bloody fight that followed, all officers and 23 privates were killed. A few were able to make their escape back to Fort Herkimer.  Joel and 5 others were captured and taken to British Fort Niagara. 

At Fort Niagara Joel had to run the gauntlet. Running the gauntlet is a former military punishment in which the offender was made to run between two rows of men who would strike with switches or weapons as he passed. Often a sergeant would walk backwards in front of the prisoner with a sword pressed against the man's belly to keep him from running, while forcing him forward with a rope tied to the man's wrists. After running the gauntlet twice, Joel was dressed in Indian clothing and given as a present to Col. Butler, a Tory or Loyalist officer, who commanded a regiment of rangers in the British Army.


Given the opportunity to take up arms against his country, Joel refused. He was confined in the guard house for 12 days. Joel was moved to a dungeon on Carleton Island in the St. Lawrence River for four weeks until he was transferred again. After an 11-month-imprisonment through the bitterly cold winter and muggy summer on an Island 40 miles above Montreal, he was moved to Montreal and then to Quebec.

The British knew the war was lost. Joel was taken on board a British ship and sailed to Boston as part of a prisoner exchange Nov. 28, 1782. A preliminary peace treaty was signed in Paris two days later.   Joel had been a British prisoner for nearly 15 months.

Meanwhile, the previous June (1782), 18-year-old Rogers had enlisted as a soldier in Berkshire County, Massachusetts, for the term of three years.  Immediately upon conscription, he marched nearly 60 miles to Springfield, Massachusetts, where he was mustered by an officer sent from the Continental Army.  The recruits trained at Springfield and then marched 130 miles to West Point.

Upon arrival at West Point, Rogers served in the 6th Massachusetts Regiment commandeered by Col. John Kilby Smith. Later that year they joined the French Army and marched 15 miles south to Verplanck Point.  In the fall of the same year, the troops marched 24 miles north to New Windsor where they erected huts for Winter Quarters.   After finishing huts for officers and soldiers, they erected a large building for meetings and a conference house for the officers.  The news of the peace treaty (Nov. 30, 1782) arrived with great rejoicing, and those who had enlisted for the duration of the war were discharged upon six months furlough. Rogers received orders to march to West Point.  

In June 1783 Rogers marched with troops to Philadelphia to quell the violence. Distressed at receiving no pay for their service during the Revolutionary War, 400 Continental soldiers stationed in Philadelphia mutinied. Attempting an attack on Congress, they proceeded to break open the Bank to obtain their pay.  Rogers wrote, “On our march we passed by a number of the members of Congress in Princeton who had fled there for safety who stood with heads uncovered and their hats in their hands until our brigade had passed them.  When we arrived at Philadelphia the mob was dispersed, two of the leaders having been taken and sentenced to be shot but were subsequently reprieved.” 

On Sept. 3, 1783, The United States and Great Britain signed the Treaty of Paris. In the fall Rogers returned to West Point where he remained, except for a 3-4 week furlough in November 1783, until he was discharged about the first of May 1784. 


Unlike his brother Joel, Rogers never was in battle with the British nor the Indians. He was never forced to run the gauntlet. He was not a prisoner of war. Yet both brothers served their country during the American Revolution.  

Source of information: Revolutionary War pension records for Rogers Savage and Joel Savage.




Wednesday, January 8, 2020

John A. Whetten's Cousin Hattie Savage


JOHN A.'S COUSIN HATTIE
            
John A. Whetten
Harriet J. Savage
I doubt my grandfather, John A. Whetten, ever met his 2nd cousin Harriet Jane Savage (their grandfathers were brothers--David Leonard Savage and Jehiel Savage) as he grew up in Mexico and she in Utah in the day of horse and wagon. I had never heard of Hattie until she made the news recently. 

Although Hattie had the unfortunate luck to marry Joseph Henry King Loveless in 1899, she got off lucky.  She filed for divorce on grounds of desertion and failure to provide for her and their daughter, Lovina Thelma Loveless. Good move. In 1904 Hattie married Albert Orlando Leavitt in Provo, Utah, and I hope she was happy.  The couple had 6 more children.

In 1905 Joe married the unfortunate Agnes Octavia Caldwell in Bear Lake, Idaho, and 4 children were born to them.  Eleven years later, he murdered Agnes with an axe. In and out of prison for bootlegging, “at Agnes' funeral one of her children was quoted as saying, ‘Papa never stayed in jail very long and he'll soon be out.’ Several days later, a ‘Walter Cairns’ (his then alias) escaped from jail by sawing through the bars using a saw he had hidden in his shoe.” 

It is believed Joe (or Walter) was killed shortly after his jail break in May 1916, dismembered and hid in a cave near Dubois, Idaho. Body parts were discovered in 1979 and 1991. DNA Doe Project, a nonprofit organization that identifies Jane and John Does through advanced genetic genealogy techniques, became involved with the cold case and identified the man.


Referenced by Dick Eastman, Jan. 2, 2020, Human Remains Found in Idaho Cave Identified as Outlaw Who Died Over 100 Years Ago https://blog.eogn.com/2020/01/02/human-remains-found-in-idaho-cave-identified-as-outlaw-who-died-over-100-years-ago/  Used with permission.